Click
here to close Hello! We notice that
you are using Internet Explorer, which is not supported by Echinobase
and may cause the site to display incorrectly. We suggest using a
current version of Chrome,
FireFox,
or Safari.
Sci Adv
2020 Dec 11;650:. doi: 10.1126/sciadv.abc5162.
Show Gene links
Show Anatomy links
Topology-dependent asymmetry in systematic errors affects phylogenetic placement of Ctenophora and Xenacoelomorpha.
Kapli P
,
Telford MJ
.
Abstract
The evolutionary relationships of two animal phyla, Ctenophora and Xenacoelomorpha, have proved highly contentious. Ctenophora have been proposed as the most distant relatives of all other animals (Ctenophora-first rather than the traditional Porifera-first). Xenacoelomorpha may be primitively simple relatives of all other bilaterally symmetrical animals (Nephrozoa) or simplified relatives of echinoderms and hemichordates (Xenambulacraria). In both cases, one of the alternative topologies must be a result of errors in tree reconstruction. Here, using empirical data and simulations, we show that the Ctenophora-first and Nephrozoa topologies (but not Porifera-first and Ambulacraria topologies) are strongly supported by analyses affected by systematic errors. Accommodating this finding suggests that empirical studies supporting Ctenophora-first and Nephrozoa trees are likely to be explained by systematic error. This would imply that the alternative Porifera-first and Xenambulacraria topologies, which are supported by analyses designed to minimize systematic error, are the most credible current alternatives.
Fig. 1. Phylogenetic tree of main animal groups highlighting alternative hypotheses for the positions of the Ctenophora and Xenacoelomorpha.The dotted lines show alternative positions for the Ctenophora and Xenacoelomorpha. The sister group of all other Metazoa could be Ctenophora (Ctenophora-first) or the Porifera (Porifera-first). Xenacoelomorpha could be the sister group of the Ambulacraria (Xenambulacraria hypothesis), or the Xenacoelomorpha could be the sister group of all other Bilateria (Nephrozoa hypothesis). Branch lengths are approximately proportional to the average branch lengths leading to the clades indicated. Long branches leading to Ctenophora and Xenacoelomorpha are evident. The Chordata are shown as a sister group of the Protostomia: a topology supported by the dataset used in our analyses (9).
Fig. 2. Site-homogeneous models consistently underestimate branch lengths.(A) Tree showing the clades (names) and branches (letters) for which lengths were estimated using Philippe-all data. (B) Estimates of clade and branch lengths using site-heterogeneous model (blue) and site-homogeneous model (brown) based on empirical data. (C) Tree showing the clades and branches for which lengths were estimated using Simion-all data. (D) Estimates of clade and branch lengths using site-heterogeneous (blue) model and site-homogeneous model (brown) based on empirical data. Site-homogeneous models consistently estimate shorter branch lengths.
Fig. 3. Site-heterogeneous models estimate accurate branch lengths for both site-homogeneous and site-heterogeneous data.(A) The guide tree that was used for simulating the data, showing the clades (names) and branches (letters) used for comparing the estimates across models. (B) Estimates of clade and branch lengths for data simulated under the site-homogeneous model and inferred using the site-heterogeneous model (blue) and site-homogeneous model (brown). Both models give similarly accurate branch lengths for data simulated with the site-homogeneous model; the true branch lengths are shown with the black lines. (C) Equivalent estimates of clade and branch lengths for data simulated under the site-heterogeneous model. Site-heterogeneous models give accurate estimates, whereas site-homogeneous models consistently underestimate the amount of change/branch length.
Fig. 4. Topology-dependent asymmetry of the ability of model-violating site-homogeneous models to reconstruct the correct tree.(A) A total of 100 datasets were simulated using a site-heterogeneous model for each of the topologies shown (orange/gray boxes). (B) For the datasets based on the whole alignment, site-heterogeneous (top) and site-homogeneous models (bottom) were used to reconstruct a maximum likelihood tree. The proportion of times the orange or black tree was reconstructed is shown in the bar charts. Data simulated under the Nephrozoa and the Ctenophora-first trees always yield the correct topology regardless of the model. Data simulated under the Xenambulacraria and Porifera-first topologies mostly yield the correct topology under the site-heterogeneous model but an incorrect topology under the site-homogeneous model. The incorrect tree is always Nephrozoa and the Ctenophora-first, respectively. (C) The experiments were repeated for the datasets based on the sets of genes best and worst at reconstructing known clades. For the best genes under both models, the inference is improved for data simulated under Xenambulacraria and Porifera-first topologies. A decrease in the performance of both models is observed using the worst data.
Fig. 5. Topology-dependent asymmetry of tree reconstruction analyses shown using bootstrap.(A) A total of 100 datasets were simulated using a site-heterogeneous model for each of topologies shown in the corresponding box plots (orange/gray boxes). (B) Site-heterogeneous (top) and site-homogeneous models (bottom) were used to reconstruct a maximum likelihood tree, with the bootstrap support measured. The bootstrap support values showing the support of either gray or orange topologies are shown in the bar charts. Data simulated under the Nephrozoa and the Ctenophora-first trees always yield the correct topology regardless of the model with 100% bootstrap support. Data simulated under the Xenambulacraria and Porifera-first topologies mostly yield the correct topology under the site-heterogeneous model but an incorrect topology under the site-homogeneous model. The incorrect tree is always Nephrozoa or Ctenophora-first, respectively.
Fig. 6. Best genes have short terminal branches and longer internal branches.(A) A tree showing the clades (names) and branches (letters) for which lengths were estimated for the Philippe data. (B) Estimates of clade and branch lengths for empirical data using a site-heterogeneous model for three data samples: best genes (green, highest monophyly scores), all dataset (gray), and worst genes (black, lowest monophyly scores). Best genes have shorter terminal branches within clades than all or worst. Best genes have longer branches separating clades than all or worst. (C) A tree showing the clades (names) and branches (letters) for which lengths were estimated for the Simion data. (D) Estimates of clade and branch lengths for the Simion-best, Simion-all and Simion-worst genes. Best genes have shorter terminal branches within clades than all or worst. For the best genes, most internal branches are the same or longer than for all or worst genes with the exception of the internal branch leading to the Ctenophora clade.
Aguinaldo,
Evidence for a clade of nematodes, arthropods and other moulting animals.
1997, Pubmed
Aguinaldo,
Evidence for a clade of nematodes, arthropods and other moulting animals.
1997,
Pubmed
Bergsten,
A review of long-branch attraction.
2005,
Pubmed
Bourlat,
Deuterostome phylogeny reveals monophyletic chordates and the new phylum Xenoturbellida.
2006,
Pubmed
,
Echinobase
Cannon,
Xenacoelomorpha is the sister group to Nephrozoa.
2016,
Pubmed
Dunn,
Broad phylogenomic sampling improves resolution of the animal tree of life.
2008,
Pubmed
Hejnol,
Assessing the root of bilaterian animals with scalable phylogenomic methods.
2009,
Pubmed
Hillis,
Application and accuracy of molecular phylogenies.
1994,
Pubmed
Hoang,
UFBoot2: Improving the Ultrafast Bootstrap Approximation.
2018,
Pubmed
Kapli,
Phylogenetic tree building in the genomic age.
2020,
Pubmed
Kim,
A new perspective on lower metazoan relationships from 18S rDNA sequences.
1999,
Pubmed
King,
Embracing Uncertainty in Reconstructing Early Animal Evolution.
2017,
Pubmed
Lartillot,
PhyloBayes MPI: phylogenetic reconstruction with infinite mixtures of profiles in a parallel environment.
2013,
Pubmed
Lartillot,
Suppression of long-branch attraction artefacts in the animal phylogeny using a site-heterogeneous model.
2007,
Pubmed
Nguyen,
IQ-TREE: a fast and effective stochastic algorithm for estimating maximum-likelihood phylogenies.
2015,
Pubmed
Philippe,
Acoelomorph flatworms are deuterostomes related to Xenoturbella.
2011,
Pubmed
,
Echinobase
Philippe,
Mitigating Anticipated Effects of Systematic Errors Supports Sister-Group Relationship between Xenacoelomorpha and Ambulacraria.
2019,
Pubmed
,
Echinobase
Pisani,
Genomic data do not support comb jellies as the sister group to all other animals.
2015,
Pubmed
Quang,
Empirical profile mixture models for phylogenetic reconstruction.
2008,
Pubmed
Roure,
Site-specific time heterogeneity of the substitution process and its impact on phylogenetic inference.
2011,
Pubmed
Rouse,
New deep-sea species of Xenoturbella and the position of Xenacoelomorpha.
2016,
Pubmed
Ryan,
The genome of the ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi and its implications for cell type evolution.
2013,
Pubmed
Siddall,
Success of Parsimony in the Four-Taxon Case: Long-Branch Repulsion by Likelihood in the Farris Zone.
1998,
Pubmed
Simion,
A Large and Consistent Phylogenomic Dataset Supports Sponges as the Sister Group to All Other Animals.
2017,
Pubmed
Stamatakis,
RAxML version 8: a tool for phylogenetic analysis and post-analysis of large phylogenies.
2014,
Pubmed
Swofford,
Bias in phylogenetic estimation and its relevance to the choice between parsimony and likelihood methods.
2001,
Pubmed
Wang,
Modeling Site Heterogeneity with Posterior Mean Site Frequency Profiles Accelerates Accurate Phylogenomic Estimation.
2018,
Pubmed
Wang,
A class frequency mixture model that adjusts for site-specific amino acid frequencies and improves inference of protein phylogeny.
2008,
Pubmed
Whelan,
Who Let the CAT Out of the Bag? Accurately Dealing with Substitutional Heterogeneity in Phylogenomic Analyses.
2017,
Pubmed
Whelan,
Error, signal, and the placement of Ctenophora sister to all other animals.
2015,
Pubmed
Zou,
Amino acid exchangeabilities vary across the tree of life.
2019,
Pubmed